Round vs Oval Toilet Seat: Choosing the Best Shape for Your Bathroom

Choosing the right toilet seat is essential for comfort and bathroom design coherence. As a seasoned home improvement enthusiast with a focus on bathroom fixtures, I’ve come to appreciate the subtle differences between round and oval (elongated) toilet seats. The choice is not merely aesthetic; it impacts user comfort, toilet dimensions, and even water consumption patterns.

Round toilet seats are the traditional choice, characterized by their circular shape. They typically measure about 16.5 inches in length, making them a space-efficient option for smaller bathrooms. On the other hand, oval toilet seats, often referred to as elongated, are roughly 18.5 inches in length, offering additional comfort thanks to their extended oval shape.

Design and Aesthetics

In my years as an interior designer, I’ve noticed the significant impact that toilet seat shape has on a bathroom’s overall look and feel. The right choice can complement the aesthetic, whether you’re aiming for modern flair or traditional coziness.

Comparing Shapes

Elongated Seats: An elongated or oval toilet seat is typically 18.5 inches long, creating a sleek appearance. Its shape is more rectangular with a rounded end, often suited for modern and minimalist styles.

Round Seats: Round toilet seats are typically about 16 to 16.5 inches long and fit well in compact spaces. They maintain a circular shape, embodying a traditional look that fits well in classic bathroom designs.

Color and Material Choices

  • Materials: The material of a toilet seat significantly influences the bathroom’s aesthetics. I prefer wood for a warmer, richer look, and plastic for a wide variety of colors and a more contemporary vibe.
  • Colors: You can find toilet seats in an array of colors. Bold hues can serve as an accent piece, while neutral tones like white, beige, or gray work best to create a clean, uniform look.

Style Integration in Modern Bathrooms

In contemporary bathrooms, integrating the toilet seat into the overall design scheme is essential. Elongated seats are often associated with modern aesthetics, aligning with the bathroom trends that favor clean lines and minimalistic features.

Round seats, though perfect for traditional settings, can also complement modern designs when selected in the right color and material.

Comfort and Dimensions

In my professional experience, the choice between round and oval toilet seats significantly influences both comfort and restroom space efficiency. Personal comfort and compatibility with the toilet bowl size are key considerations.

Ergonomics of Seating

I’ve found that oval or elongated toilet seats tend to offer more comfort for adults due to their increased surface area, providing better support.

The elongated shape typically measures about 18 to 19 inches from the hinges to the front edge, aligning with the natural contours of the human body. This additional length can be especially advantageous for taller individuals or those seeking extra support.

Size and Space Considerations

Room dimensions play a crucial role in choosing the right toilet seat. I always recommend measuring the available space before making a decision. Round toilet seats are usually 16 to 16.5 inches in length and fit well in more compact bathroom layouts. Here’s a simple way to determine suitable seat dimensions for your space:

  • Elongated seats: Require more room from wall to front of bowl
  • Round seats: More appropriate for restricted spaces, offering adequate comfort without compromising on the functionality

Toilet Bowl Compatibility

Matching the toilet seat to the toilet bowl is essential for both aesthetics and function. As a guideline:

  • Elongated toilets: Measure from the post holes to the bowl’s front edge to ensure it’s around 18.5 inches
  • Round toilets: Verify if the length is approximately 16.5 inches

For ADA-compliant toilets, often referred to as “comfort height,” the right seat is crucial to capitalize on the height’s benefits. An elongated seat on these bowls provides more support and enhances comfort for adults. Always verify seat and toilet bowl compatibility for a seamless fit.

Installation and Maintenance

When installing or maintaining a toilet seat, focusing on ease of cleaning, the actual installation process, and the seat’s durability is essential. I’ve found that certain features like quick-release hinges and soft-close functions can significantly enhance the overall experience.

Ease of Cleaning

Toilet seats should be hygienic and easy to clean to maintain a healthy environment. In my experience, quick-release toilet seats are a game-changer. They allow the seat to be removed quickly for more thorough cleaning.

Look for seats with a smooth surface and minimal crevices to make wiping down simpler and more effective. Materials like polypropylene are stain-resistant and help keep the toilet hygienic.

Installation Process

When installing a toilet seat, measuring is critical for a proper fit. Standard toilet seats have bolt holes that match the standard height and width of most toilets but always measure the distance between the bolt holes to ensure compatibility. Here’s a simplified installation process:

  1. Measure the width of the toilet bowl at its widest point.
  2. Measure the distance from the front of the toilet bowl to the center of the bolt holes.
  3. Align the new seat’s hinges with the bolt holes, and insert the bolts.
  4. Tighten the nuts by hand and then with a wrench to secure.

For the best results, choose a seat with adjustable hinges to align with the bolt holes of your toilet.

Durability and Replacement

The durability of toilet seats varies across materials and usage. In my professional experience, I recommend looking for materials known for their longevity, such as enameled wood or high-quality plastics.

Maintenance includes periodic tightening of the bolts since loosening over time is common. A soft-close feature can prevent slamming, minimizing wear and tear. When it’s time for replacement, remember that most seats are standard sized, but measuring is always prudent to ensure a seamless fit.

Cost Factors and Considerations

In my experience, understanding the nuances in pricing between round and elongated toilet seats is crucial for making an informed purchase. I will break down the components that affect the cost.

Price Point Analysis

Round toilet seats are traditionally less expensive due to their simple design and smaller size. Elongated seats, measuring around 18.5 inches, often come at a premium. This difference in cost may affect your decision if you’re working with a strict budget.

  • Round Toilet Seats: Generally cheaper
  • Elongated Toilet Seats: Typically more expensive due to additional material

Material and Brand Implications

The material of a toilet seat significantly impacts its price. Plastic seats, common in both shapes, tend to be more affordable, while wooden or polyresin variants cost more. Brand reputation plays a role as well—Kohler, Toto, and American Standard are often higher-priced but offer perceived value for money based on durability and design.

  • Plastic: Cheaper
  • Wood/Polyresin: More expensive
  • Brand Examples: More recognition — Kohler, Toto, American Standard — usually equates to higher prices.

Longevity and Value

Despite initial costs, the longevity of a toilet seat must be considered. I’ve found that cheaper models might need replacing more frequently, while investment in a reputable brand like Mayfair could provide better value over time, regardless of the seat shape.

  • Cheaper Models: May require sooner replacements
  • Reputable Brands: Higher upfront cost, but often more cost-effective long-term
BrandMaterialShapeAverage Cost
American StandardPlasticRound$$

My guidance here aims to equip you with the knowledge to weigh the balance between price, material, brand reputation, and potential long-term value when selecting your next toilet seat.

Let Us Know How We’re Doing!

Did this expertly prepared resource answer your question?

Do you have another question about home maintenance, home improvement projects, home appliance repair, or something else?

Get more information, send in questions and keep the discussion going by contacting the I’ll Just Fix It Myself company customer service team at at 1-800-928-1490 or Email us at [email protected]