Kohler Highline Arc Toilet vs Cimarron: An In-Depth Comparison

When selecting a toilet for a home, the decision often comes down to balancing style, efficiency, and comfort. In my professional experience, I find Kohler to be a brand that consistently meets these needs, and two of its models, the Highline Arc and the Cimarron, stand out. As someone who has spent considerable time evaluating and installing various toilet models, I can offer a clear and neutral comparison to help homeowners make an informed choice.

The Kohler Highline Arc and the Cimarron toilets both bring a combination of sleek design and reliable functionality to the table. Having worked with both, I’ve seen first-hand how their features cater to different preferences.

The Highline Arc, with its elegant curves and taller seating, prioritizes comfort and aesthetics, while the Cimarron aims for water efficiency and powerful flushing technology. Understanding the nuanced differences between the two can lead to a confident decision that suits one’s specific bathroom needs.

Design and Features Comparison

When researching toilets for my bathroom renovations, I found the Kohler Highline Arc and the Cimarron have distinct characteristics that cater to different preferences and requirements. Let’s compare their design and features to see which might be the best choice for your bathroom.

Dimensional Differences

The Kohler Highline Arc and Cimarron toilets vary in dimensions, affecting fit and comfort. Highline Arc models offer a comfort height design, commonly referred to as chair height, which stands at about 17 inches, making it ADA compliant and comfortable for most adults.

Cimarron models also provide a comfort height feature, ensuring they meet the comfort needs of a wide range of users. Both lines have elongated bowls providing additional room and comfort.

Table: Dimensions of Kohler Highline Arc vs. Cimarron

FeatureKohler Highline ArcKohler Cimarron
Bowl ShapeElongatedElongated, Round Available
HeightComfort Height (17+ Inches)Comfort Height (17+ Inches)
Two-Piece/One-PieceTwo-PieceTwo-Piece & One-Piece

Flushing System and Performance

Both the Highline Arc and Cimarron incorporate powerful and efficient flushing systems. I’ve observed that the Highline Arc uses a Class Five flushing system for a potent and effective flush. On the other hand, the Cimarron uses an AquaPiston flush, which provides a strong siphonic action, reducing clog incidents.

  • Highline Arc: Class Five Flushing System
  • Cimarron: AquaPiston flush, Canister Flush Valve

The WaterSense certification on certain models means they are designed to conserve water without sacrificing performance, which is a crucial feature for those looking to reduce their water usage.

Installation and Maintenance

From my installation experience, I can confirm both Kohler lines are designed with easy installation in mind, with the two-piece design of Highline Arc being slightly easier to manage due to reduced weight of each piece. The one-piece models of Cimarron, while heavier, offer a sleek design that can make cleaning more straightforward with fewer crevices.

In terms of maintenance, the glazed trapway and canister flush valve on both lines provide clog-free performance and simplify the task of keeping the toilet functioning smoothly.

Aesthetics and Material Quality

Kohler has designed both lines with attention to aesthetics and material quality. Highline Arc and Cimarron toilets are constructed from vitreous china, offering durability and a glossy finish that retains its luster.

The Cimarron line has an optional skirted trap design, which gives it a streamlined, sleek look, and comes in an array of colors, allowing customization to fit a variety of bathroom decors. The Highline Arc offers a classic, clean style that fits in well with traditional and contemporary bathrooms alike.

Cost and Value Considerations

When comparing the Kohler Highline Arc toilet with the Cimarron, it’s crucial to assess their cost and value. Through my hands-on experience and industry knowledge, I have observed various factors, such as price and water efficiency, affecting homeowners’ decisions.

Initial Purchase Price

The Kohler Highline Arc is generally known for its affordability, catering to a budget-conscious homeowner without sacrificing quality. Its price typically aligns with the needs of average homeowners looking for a durable upgrade. On the other hand, the Kohler Cimarron is priced slightly higher, reflecting its additional features and benefits, which might be worth the investment for those prioritizing design and functionality.

Long-Term Value

The longevity and durability of a flushing toilet are as important as the initial cost. Both toilets usually come with a one-year limited warranty, but the true value extends to performance over time. I’ve found that the robust build of both models can withstand years of use, contributing to their overall long-term value.

Water Efficiency and Consumption

  • Highline Arc: Typically uses 1.28 gallons per flush (GPF) and has an EPA WaterSense certification for water conservation.
  • Cimarron: Offers options between 1.28 GPF and 1.6 GPF, some being EPA WaterSense certified as well, indicating high water efficiency.

Lower GPF contributes to reduced water usage, yielding cost savings on water bills and supporting water conservation efforts.

Availability and Options

The Kohler Highline and Cimarron provide various options to suit diverse preferences. While both have color options and designs that comply with ADA guidelines, the Cimarron’s line sometimes offers a dual-flush mechanism, allowing for further water efficiency by giving the option to choose the volume for each flush. This customization is a significant consideration for those looking to tailor their bathroom fixtures to specific needs and style preferences.

Compliance and Certifications

In my experience, understanding the compliance and certifications of bathroom fixtures is essential for making an informed choice. When comparing the Kohler Highline Arc toilet with the Cimarron model, it’s important to recognize their certifications which reflect their commitment to efficiency and accessibility.

ADA Compliant
Both toilets meet the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) standards for accessible design. This means they have a comfort height feature, which offers a chair-height seating that makes sitting down and standing up easier for most adults.

WaterSense Certification
The Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) WaterSense program endorses fixtures that are environmentally friendly and help save water without sacrificing performance. Both the Kohler Highline Arc and Cimarron toilets carry this label, meaning they’re certified to use 20% less water than the standard 1.6-gallon models without compromising flushing power.

Efficiency Stats at a Glance:

CategoryKohler Highline ArcKohler Cimarron
Flushing TechnologyAquaPistonAquaPiston
Water Consumption1.28 GPF1.28 GPF or 1.6 GPF
EPA WaterSense CertifiedYesYes
ADA CompliantYesYes

By selecting a model that adheres to these standards, I’m opting for a toilet that not only meets my needs for accessibility but also aligns with my environmental values. This knowledge is crucial for making a responsible and satisfying purchase.

Overall Comparison and Recommendations

In comparing the Kohler Highline Arc and Cimarron toilets, I’m focusing on their distinctive attributes. This will guide you in making the best choice for your home.

Summarizing the Differences

Kohler Highline Arc:

  • Water Consumption: 1.28 gallons per flush (GPF)
  • Design: Two-piece elongated toilet
  • Flushing System: Class Five flushing technology
  • Comfort: Comfort height seating

Kohler Cimarron:

  • Water Consumption: 1.28 GPF; also available in dual-flush
  • Design: Two-piece with elongated or round bowl option
  • Flushing System: AquaPiston technology
  • Comfort: Comfort height seating
FeatureKohler Highline ArcKohler Cimarron
Water Consumption1.28 GPF1.28 GPF / Dual-flush option
DesignTwo-piece, elongatedTwo-piece, elongated or round bowl
Flushing SystemClass FiveAquaPiston
Comfort HeightYesYes
Flush PerformancePowerfulPowerful, improved by AquaPiston
MaterialVitreous chinaVitreous china
TrapwayStandard exposed trapwayFully glazed trapway
Rough-inStandard 12-inchStandard 12-inch
WarrantyOne-year limited warrantyOne-year limited warranty

Choosing According to Needs

When deciding, consider the layout and size of your bathroom. The Cimarron’s round bowl is advantageous for small spaces, whereas the Highline Arc is elongated, better suited for larger bathrooms. Water-saving is critical for many; both models offer excellent water efficiency, with the Cimarron also providing a dual-flush option for even greater savings on water.

Final Assessment for Consumers

Both the Kohler Highline Arc and Cimarron are strong contenders within the toilet market. They offer power, efficiency, and comfort. The Highline Arc is highly dependable with a traditional design and the Cimarron stands out with its versatile flushing options and potential for water conservation.

Homeowners should consider their specific needs related to design, space, and water efficiency when choosing between these two models.

Let Us Know How We’re Doing!

Did this expertly prepared resource answer your question?

Do you have another question about home maintenance, home improvement projects, home appliance repair, or something else?

Get more information, send in questions and keep the discussion going by contacting the I’ll Just Fix It Myself company customer service team at at 1-800-928-1490 or Email us at [email protected]