Project Source Toilet vs American Standard: An Unbiased Comparison

In my professional experience with bathroom fixtures, choosing between brands like Project Source and American Standard requires a careful consideration of quality, design, and value. Project Source toilets are often recognized for their practical design, while American Standard is a household name that frequently sets the bar for durability and innovation in the industry.

Evaluating toilets is more than just a matter of comparing price tags. It’s essential to weigh the design features, such as the width of the toilet base which impacts stability, against the technological advances like those offered in various American Standard models. Having installed and serviced multiple toilet brands professionally, I appreciate the subtle differences that can significantly affect user satisfaction over time.

Comparative Analysis of Toilets

In my professional experience, comparing toilets from Project Source and American Standard requires a focus on specific models, as each brand offers a range of options. Let’s examine the standout features and drawbacks to consider.

Design and Installation Comparisons

Project Source toilets typically offer a practical design with a base width similar to the bowl, ensuring a sleek design. Installation may be straightforward, coming across as adequate for DIY enthusiasts.

American Standard, on the other hand, provides a wide variety of design options, from one-piece to two-piece toilets, with elongated and round bowls that can cater to different preferences.

Efficiency and Water Usage

Both brands favor high-efficiency models with several options featuring WaterSense certification.

For instance, a dual-flush system in some American Standard models like the H2Optimum Siphonic Toilet helps conserve water. Similarly, Project Source toilets aim for efficiency with a focus on lower gallons per flush without compromising performance.

Flushing Technology and Performance

In terms of flushing power, American Standard toilets often come with proprietary technology like the Champion 4 flushing system, known for handling solid waste effectively.

Project Source toilets may feature standard gravity-fed flush systems that are reliable, though they may not match the flushing performance of high-end American Standard models.

Comfort and Accessibility Features

American Standard toilets are known for their comfort height feature, making them more accessible for users with mobility issues. They also offer a variety of seat shapes and accessories.

Project Source’s design considerations also include comfort but might have fewer comfort-enhancing options.

Brand Reputation and Consumer Insights

Consumer reviews and insights tend to be favorable for American Standard models due to their reliability and the brand’s longstanding reputation.

Project Source, while perhaps less well-known, is often acknowledged for its value, especially in terms of its cost-effective solutions for budget-conscious consumers.

Pricing and Value Evaluation

For those on a tight budget, Project Source toilets often represent a lower price point with satisfactory functionality.

American Standard toilets, although sometimes more expensive, reflect their price in durable build quality and advanced features, which may justify the extra expense for long-term value.

Environmental Compliance and Certifications

Environmental compliance is a focus for both brands, with American Standard offering WaterSense certified toilets that comply with stringent EPA guidelines.

Project Source too aligns with water conservation laws, such as those in California and Texas, ensuring their models are both eco-friendly and compliant with regulations.

Maintenance and Longevity

In my experience with bathroom fixtures, maintenance and longevity are crucial for choosing a toilet. Whether you opt for a Project Source toilet or an American Standard Champion, it’s the day-to-day cleaning and long-term durability that affect satisfaction over time.

Cleaning and Stain Resistance

Project Source toilets have a practical design that aids in cleaning, with the base width similar to the bowl, reducing corners where dirt might hide. American Standard Champion models often feature a fully glazed trapway, which not only helps in preventing clogs but also facilitates easier bowl cleaning and stain resistance.

  • Cleaning Easy Score:
    • Project Source (7/10)
    • American Standard Champion (8/10)

Repairs and Durability

The durability of a toilet is paramount. While Project Source offers quality at an approachable price point, the American Standard Champion series is recognized for its robustness, often suggested by plumbers as a reliable option. Their high-quality materials hold up well over years of use.

  • Durability Rating:
    • Project Source (Good)
    • American Standard Champion (Excellent)

Warranty and Service Expectations

American Standard often provides a more comprehensive warranty, which reflects their confidence in product reliability. Project Source does offer warranties but may not cover as many years as some other brands, like American Standard.

  • Warranty Length:
    • Project Source (Limited)
    • American Standard (Extensive)

Common Issues and Solutions

Neither brand is immune to common issues like clogging or odors in the drain line. Project Source and American Standard toilets usually clear clogs with a plunger due to their effective flush. For odorous challenges, routine cleaning and checking the seal can provide simple solutions.

  • Issue Handling: Both brands offer effective flush systems for clogged lines, reducing plumber visits.

Upgrades and Accessories

Both brands support upgrades with accessories like bidet attachments or soft-close lids. American Standard offers proprietary touchless flush kits, while both brands provide universal parts available at Home Depot and other hardware stores.

  • Accessory Compatibility: Both brands are compatible with various market upgrades, enhancing functionality.

My firsthand use and installation of these toilets across many homes have shown me that while both Project Source and American Standard Champion are solid choices, each brand shines in different aspects of maintenance and longevity.

Legislation and Industry Standards

In my experience with toilets, legislation and industry standards play a pivotal role in shaping the products offered by manufacturers like Project Source and American Standard. They ensure water conservation, certify performance, and address accessibility needs.

Water Conservation Laws

The United States has enacted laws aimed at water conservation, significantly impacting toilet designs. In 1994, the federal law mandated that all new toilets sold in the U.S. must use no more than 1.6 gallons per flush (gpf).

States like California and Texas have since imposed even stricter requirements to cope with water scarcity. For instance, California’s standards necessitate high-efficiency toilets (HET) that use 1.28 gpf or less.

  • California: Max 1.28 gpf
  • Texas: Max 1.28 gpf
  • Federal Standard: Max 1.6 gpf

Certifications and Ratings

When selecting a toilet, I always look for WaterSense certification. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) grants WaterSense certification to toilets that meet rigorous criteria for water efficiency and performance.

Such toilets not only save water but also reduce water bills. Another important metric is the Maximum Performance (MaP) score, which reflects a toilet’s waste removal efficiency. A higher MaP score signifies better waste removal.

  • WaterSense Certification: Max 1.28 gpf, performance criteria met
  • MaP Score: Waste removal efficiency rating

Accessibility Compliance

Accessibility is crucial for toilets, and the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) sets standards for toilets to be more accessible. Often termed “comfort height,” these toilets have a higher seat, similar to the height of a standard chair, to aid in easier use for individuals with disabilities.

The height, measured from the floor to the top of the seat, should fall within 17 to 19 inches.

  • ADA Compliant Height: 17-19 inches from floor to seat top
  • Standard Height: Lower than ADA compliant toilets

Consumer Decision-Making Guide

When choosing between Project Source and American Standard toilets, it’s crucial to understand your requirements, evaluate cost-effectiveness, and consider post-purchase aspects. Based on my experience, I’ll offer a straightforward guide to assist you through this process.

Assessment of Needs and Preferences

American Standard toilets are renowned for their variety, offering options from dual-flush to water-saving models, catering to diverse needs.

In contrast, Project Source provides a more focused lineup, often appealing to budget-conscious consumers seeking simple, functional designs. I recommend examining aspects like flushing power, water efficiency, and design to ensure the chosen model aligns with your lifestyle.

  • Flushing Performance: Look for high ratings in solid waste removal.
  • Comfort: Consider the height and shape for comfortable use.
  • Type of Toilet: Whether traditional gravity-feed or modern pressure-assisted.

Budget Considerations

The price of toilets can range significantly, with Project Source often positioned as a value-oriented brand, while American Standard spans from mid-tier to premium models. Remember to factor in long-term water savings, especially if considering eco-friendly options like dual-flush toilets.

  • Initial Cost: Project Source is usually more affordable than many American Standard models.
  • Water Use: Opting for water-efficient toilets can lead to savings on utility bills.

Comparative Review of Models

From my research and hands-on experience, American Standard toilets generally have more robust features, which is reflected in their higher price point. Project Source toilets, while less expensive, can still deliver respectable performance and are often found at retailers like Home Depot, making them more accessible.

  • Consumer Reports Ratings: Helpful for gauging overall performance.
  • Reviews: Check customer feedback for real-world insights into each brand.

Installation and DIY Potential

Ease of installation is an important consideration. Both brands offer models that are friendly to DIY enthusiasts, although some complex installations might require a professional plumber. The type of plumbing system you have in place can also affect installation ease.

  • Installation Kits: Some toilets come with all necessary components.
  • Plumbing System Compatibility: Ensure the chosen model fits your home’s plumbing.

After-Purchase Support and Community

After your purchase, support becomes key. American Standard typically offers a more extensive network for customer service. In comparison, Project Source may have limitations in after-purchase support, but this varies by retailer.

  • Warranty: Look into the duration and coverage details.
  • Community Forums: Places like Home Depot often have forums for discussions and advice.

Let Us Know How We’re Doing!

Did this expertly prepared resource answer your question?

Do you have another question about home maintenance, home improvement projects, home appliance repair, or something else?

Get more information, send in questions and keep the discussion going by contacting the I’ll Just Fix It Myself company customer service team at at 1-800-928-1490 or Email us at [email protected]